Tips, Courtesy of the Local 704 President
As we approach the mid-year (June/July) evaluations, here are
some suggestions that you may wish to consider now that the Performance
Appraisal and Recognition System (PARS) contractual agreement between
the American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) and U.S.
EPA is “almost” final. Specifically, it is under Agency
Head Review, having been signed by the Chief Negotiators for the
U.S. EPA and AFGE.
1. Be sure to insist that you be allowed to work "collaboratively" with
your supervisor in developing your Critical Job Elements (CJEs)
and Performance Standards.
For example, some PARS agreements contain time frames for completing
certain work and everyone already knows that those time frames
are seldom or never met and are probably unrealistic. Sometime
in December, you should go through your existing PARS plans and
identify areas, such as deadlines, where the standards are unrealistic
and inform the supervisor of those areas and request that when
they discuss the new PARS for the next year they modify those deadlines
to make them reflect what is really needed and realistic.
Another example of how you may wish to engage in "collaboration" is
to discuss with your supervisor the rationale for some requirements.
For example, if the deadline for a work product is not mandated
by a statute or regulation or agreement with a third party, then
it may be perfectly reasonable for an employee to question the
rationale for the deadline and request it be changed to something
more appropriate.
Also, note that if there is a disagreement, you can "appeal" your
concerns to your second level supervisor.
REF: PARS Contract Preamble, Item 2, Section 10: Developing Performance
Standards, F. and K. of the PARS Article 34
2. Ensure that you have assumptions "built-in" to your
CJEs. In the event that your supervisor declines to include them,
please address your concerns in your "comments" to the
Plan.
Properly worded assumptions can be used as a tool to remind supervisor's
throughout the appraisal period, of the rationale for the assumption
and the need to ensure that it is not triggered.
If an assumption is included that certain work will be assigned,
but none has yet been assigned, that assumption can be used from
time to time to send a gentle reminder to the supervisor that
you would like to be assigned such work, or would like other
work of
a similar degree of complexity and value so that the employee
can perform at a high level.
You should ensure that your assumptions include that sufficient
resources are made available to you, including:
* time, interest and support from your supervisor and management;
* travel and training funds to maintain current knowledge, skills
and abilities, as well as to improve upon your current knowledge,
skills and abilities level; and,
* opportunities for success including, but not limited to, (a)
the creation and maintenance of relationships in diverse sectors,
both internal and external, (b) timely and adequate support and
responses from other staff including but not limited to other
Region 5 Divisions or Offices, States, contractors, whose full-time
equivalent (FTE) levels and workload are controlled by others;
and (c) availability to you of "high visibility" and
other assignments that would allow you the opportunity to function
at the "outstanding" performance level for this Critical
Job Element (CJE).
Assigned task activities are not excessive precluding fully successful
performance during a standard allotted 40 hour workweek..
REF: PARS Contract Section 10: Developing Performance Standards,
I.3, Section 11: Assumptions, B., Section 12: Content of Performance
Plans, G., and Section 14: Communicating Performance Plans, E.
PARS Contract Section 15: Assessing Employee Performance, I. ("In
the application of standards to individual employees, the Employer
will consider assumptions listed in the Performance Plan.")
See also Section 10: Developing Performance Standards, L & M.
(It is the supervisor's responsibility to addressing barriers and
taking their impact into consideration during Performance Reviews.)
3. Toot your own horn! Perhaps you have been raised to be "humble" or
to not draw undue attention to yourself by "bragging" about
your accomplishments. However, now you must. I encourage you to
send your supervisor a list of accomplishments against your CJEs
each month. If that is too often for you, then at least once per
quarter.
Remember you supervisor has 10-20 people that he or she must work
with, and will not necessarily remember all of your fine work at
the end of the year appraisal. Take it upon yourself to remind
her or him what a contribution you are to the Section, Branch,
Division, Office, Region, Agency ...
Don’t forget to focus on what was assigned to you and what
was in your standards. Organizing your self-assessment against
each CJE and using bullet points to highlight ones performance
under each CJE is probably a better way to go, than to have a long
narrative type self appraisal.
You should consider your self-appraisal as a tool to highlight
your successes.
In addition to self assessments, you should learn how the awards
process works and learn the art of self-nomination for awards,
as well as the art of getting together with your coworkers and
nominating each other for awards including team awards.
REF: PARS Contract Section 14: Communicating Performance Plans,
particularly I. (However, frequent informal reviews of performance
throughout the appraisal period are required and may be requested
by the employee or supervisor at any time.)
"Our labor unions are not narrow, self-seeking groups. They
have raised wages, shortened hours, and provided supplemental benefits.
Through collective bargaining and grievance procedures, they have
brought justice and democracy to the shop floor." President
John F. Kennedy (1962)
Fraternally yours,
John J. O'Grady
President, AFGE Local 704
U.S. EPA Region 5 (AFGE-4J)
Room 409, 77 W. Jackson Blvd.
Chicago, IL 60604-3590
Telephone: 312.886.3575
Facsimile: 312.886.3582
E-mail: AFGE.Region5@epa.gov
Web Site: http://www.AFGELocal704.org